Everyone is chasing something in dating.
A spark. A feeling. A connection.
But most people aren’t chasing just one thing. They’re chasing two.
They want the excitement that lights them up and the slow, steady warmth that provides comfort over time.
Passion and peace. Sparks and security.
Wanting both isn’t unreasonable. But it does create a problem.
Here’s the issue: The strategies that build intrigue at the beginning of a relationship are VERY different from the strategies that help you build something that lasts.
It’s not a choice of either/or, that would be simple. Instead, it’s very much the case that you need both.
However, if you don’t understand what your brain is doing, you may keep chasing relationships that feel amazing at first, but disappoint you later. Or you may have a hard time getting relationships started in the first place.
In the rest of this piece, I walk through:
How to identify whether you’re a dopamine or serotonin dater (and why this determines your relationship patterns)
The hidden danger of dopamine dating, why love bombing works so well on certain people and how to protect yourself
Why serotonin relationships feel “boring” (and the reframe that helps you recognize real love)
The trade-off most people miss: why it’s easier to add excitement to stability than stability to chaos
How to strike the right balance based on your actual relationship goals, not what feels good in the moment
The Brain Chemistry Driving Your Dating Choices
Your brain is an evolutionary masterpiece. It weighs about three pounds, roughly the size of two fists, and it runs on a complicated mix of electrical signals, chemicals, and, let’s be honest, coffee. (At least that’s 100% true in my case).
Those brain chemicals are neurotransmitters. They shape how you experience pleasure, motivation, connection, and calm. Two of them matter quite a bit for dating: dopamine and serotonin.
They’re often called “happy chemicals,” but they create very different kinds of happiness.
Dopamine is the rush. It’s not feeling good itself, but the seeking and anticipation of feeling good. It’s the chase, the what’s next? feeling. It’s the endless scroll of social media, the thrill of a match, the excitement of something new.
Serotonin is different. It’s contentment and stability. It’s feeling emotionally balanced, calm, and socially connected.
Dopamine is TikTok. Serotonin is a well-written drama you settle into over time. We chase both in our daily lives and in our love lives. Wanting a bit of both is natural. What matters though is which one you prioritize.
You Might Be a Dopamine Dater If…
…the early stages of romance feel intoxicating. Dating apps feel energizing and swiping through endless possibilities is exciting (“Look at all the possibilities!”). Even when meeting people leads nowhere, you’re buoyed by the sense that someone just a little better might be one more match away.
In dating, grand romantic gestures matter and big amazing dates feel meaningful. You want your love life to feel cinematic, not mundane. Quiet intimacy can feel boring. Attention and validation feels reassuring. Being desired is front and center.
Subtle consistency doesn’t register because it’s dull. New partners need to feel magical and they often occupy an idealized place in your thoughts. The possibility of being soulmates is top of mind.
It all sounds amazing and is what we’ve all grown up seeing on TV and in movies. Dopamine sells.
But there’s a catch.
The problem with dopamine dating isn’t that it feels bad. Quite the opposite. Excitement and attention feels really good, which makes dopamine daters susceptible to love bombing, or a manipulative tactic that overwhelms someone with excessive affection, attention, and intensity early on in order to accelerate emotional attachment (Beri, 2024). In other words, dopamine daters fall for the illusion of emotional connection easier.
Here’s the other thing…those amazing feelings are wonderful for starting relationships, but terrible at sustaining them. Once the novelty and amazingness wears off (which it always does because, as humans, we habituate to most things), the partner’s flaws show up (Note: The flaws were always there, but all the excitement makes it hard to notice/easy to ignore).
Next, we start second-guessing the connection or look for ways to infuse more dopamine (e.g., even more exciting dates, sex, jealousy, drama, or unnecessary conflict).
Unfortunately, that forced dopamine also has a short shelf-life, so it’s not long before dopamine daters look for someone new who can provide a big dose of novelty and excitement. And the cycle begins anew.
As a result, dopamine relationships tend to be short-lived.
Want the tools, frameworks, and step-by-step strategies that make the real difference between understanding something and being able to do something with it?
That’s what paid subscribers get, plus access to the full archive (everything unlocked) of science-backed scripts, exercises, and coaching frameworks from 4+ years of working with real people in real relationships.
$75/year. Less than a therapy co-pay. Infinitely more actionable.
You Might Be a Serotonin Dater If…
…the early stages of romance feel uncertain, but subtly promising. You’re cautious and tentative, rather than caught up in all the feelings. Dating apps don’t energize you so much as exhaust you. You’re less interested in endless options than in whether someone is emotionally available. You’re not chasing the next match, you’d be more than happy if the next first date you went on was you last.
Small moments matter. A thoughtful text. Showing up when they say they will. Making space for real conversation with deep emotions. Grand gestures are distractions. You want feelings, not flowers.
What you’re looking for is ease, consistency, and comfort. Connection builds gradually. Emotional safety is more appealing than emotional intensity. You don’t just want to be chosen, you want to be seen, heard, and understood.
But there’s a catch here too.
Serotonin dating is less exciting. That makes it less clear whether the other person likes you (or are they simply being nice?), or whether you like them (or do you just see them as a friend?).
You may convince yourself that you’re not really in love because the relationship is missing all of the uncertainty, mystery, and anxiety. If you feel so safe and certain, how can this really be special enough to be love?
Let’s be honest, these types of feelings can also feel boring. Stability, consistency, predictability, certainty, reliability, dependability, warmth, tenderness, caring, and comfort don’t exactly elicit rampant excitement.
In fact, those qualities scream FRIENDZONE. You’re not looking for a buddy, a pal, or even just a friend. Doubting the authenticity of your love connection is incredibly easy.
Serotonin dating feels even more foreign when it’s unfamiliar. If your previous relationships have been emotionally-charged and full of the false excitement of lots of ups and downs, stability feels unromantic. Where’s the passion in predictability and constant kindness?
But that’s what serotonin dating is all about. Moving differently, being comfortable going slow, building a foundation on friendship, and allowing the connection to develop over time.
In dating, going fast often doesn’t take you far.
Quick rarely leads to quality.
Striking a Balance: Dopamine vs. Serotonin Dating
Anthropologist Helen Fisher suggested that people who lean toward dopamine tend to be curious, spontaneous, creative, and novelty-seeking. They’re energized by new experiences and big ideas. While those who lean toward serotonin tend to be conscientious, steady, and long-term oriented. They value structure, consistency, and reliability.
Neither is necessarily better than the other.
What works best for you, depends on your goals. If you’re focused on short-term dating and aren’t looking for commitment, dopamine dating fits that approach very well.
However, if you’re looking for a long-term fulfilling and committed relationship, the serotonin style is a better match.
Serotonin-based relationships are sustainable. They prioritize stability, trust, and long-term contentment. They’re far less likely to burn out because they don’t depend on constant novelty to survive.
Yes, serotonin relationships may lack the intense highs associated with dopamine dating. They’re not constantly exciting. But ask yourself, how much regular excitement and mystery do you really want over the next few decades?
The Trade-Off Most People Miss
You can have anything, but you can’t have everything.
That’s true for most things in life, but also in love. 100% excitement and 100% stability don’t exist. You need to compromise and decide which aspect you’re going to prioritize.
But here’s the trade-off most people miss:
It’s much easier to add excitement to a stable relationship than it is to add stability to a chaotic one.
You can plan trips. Try new experiences. Introduce novelty intentionally. You can’t manufacture emotional safety after the fact.
If your partner undermines your psychological peace and safety, that’s a MUCH bigger problem, and MUCH more difficult to fix.
However, if you find a good, solid, caring, kind, respectful partner who communicates, supports you, and loves you for who you are, but is a little boring…the solutions for that problem are so much simpler.
Conclusion
Here’s what no one tells you about lasting love: It doesn’t find you. You build it.
Creating the relationship you want starts with getting brutally honest about what you’ve been chasing and why. If you keep making the same mistakes, you’ll continue to get the same results.
Start building something great that’s going to stand the test of time.
Know someone who enjoys psychology or relationships? Please help share relationship psychology with others by referring them here:
Here are other ways to learn more about the Psychology of Relationships:
My podcast: Love Strategies
My website: www.PsychologyofRelationships.com
References
Beri, R. (2024). A study on love bombing, narcissism and emotional abuse among young adults in relationship and situationship. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Approaches in Psychology, 2(6), 22–46.
Photo by Bioscience Image Library by Fayette Reynolds on Unsplash
Note: Please forgive any typos or errors. Non-AI writing has its imperfections. Consider it the patina of a personal touch.
This was absolutely terrific and put a name to what a lot of of us have gone through the last few years in the dating scene, especially post Covid. Truly, I really appreciate this article and will be sharing with my friends who were also on the dating scene!
Really appreciate how you framed “Dopamine is the rush. It’s not feeling good itself, but the seeking and anticipation of feeling good. It’s the chase, the what’s next? feeling. It’s the endless scroll of social media, the thrill of a match, the excitement of something new.
Serotonin is different. It’s contentment and stability. It’s feeling emotionally balanced, calm, and socially connected.”
I’m a therapist working on a post about sex rituals and, and this feels deeply aligned. Just subscribed—would love to stay in conversation.